When navigating the world of real estate, understanding agency relationships is crucial. Whether you’re a buyer, seller, or investor, knowing who represents your interests—or those of the other party—can make or break your transaction. One such agency relationship, often misunderstood, is subagency.
By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of this concept and how it fits into modern real estate practices.
What is a Subagency in Home Real Estate?
Subagency is a specific type of agency relationship in real estate. It involves a three-way relationship between the seller (the principal), the listing broker (the agent), and another real estate agent (the subagent). In this arrangement, the subagent works on behalf of the seller, even though they may interact directly with potential buyers.
Key Characteristics of Subagency
- The Seller is the Principal: The seller is the primary client, and their interests are the priority.
- The Listing Broker Appoints the Subagent: The listing broker, who has a direct agreement with the seller, can appoint another agent (the subagent) to assist in finding a buyer.
- Subagent Represents the Seller: Even though the subagent may work with buyers, their fiduciary duty is to the seller.
How Subagency Differs from Other Agency Relationships
- Buyer’s Agency: In a buyer’s agency, the agent exclusively represents the buyer’s interests.
- Dual Agency: In a dual agency, one agent represents both the buyer and the seller, with limited fiduciary duties to both.
- Transaction Brokerage: In this role, the agent acts as a neutral facilitator, assisting both parties without representing either party.
Understanding these distinctions is essential to grasp the unique nature of subagency.
The Historical Context of Subagency
To fully appreciate the concept of subagency, it’s helpful to understand its origins and evolution.
You may also read (steps to keep your home).
Subagency in the Past
Historically, subagency was the default agency relationship in real estate. Before the rise of the buyer’s agency, all agents involved in a transaction worked for the seller. This meant that even if a buyer approached an agent to view a property, that agent was legally obligated to represent the seller’s interests.
Why Subagency Was Common
- Lack of Buyer Representation: Buyers often didn’t have their own agents, as the concept of buyer’s agency was not yet widespread.
- Simpler Transactions: Subagency streamlined the process by aligning all agents under the seller’s interests.
The Shift Away from Subagency
Over time, the real estate industry recognized the need for buyer representation. This led to the rise of buyer’s agency, where agents exclusively advocate for buyers. As a result, subagency became less common, though it still exists in certain markets and situations.
Key Parties Involved in Subagency
To understand how subagency works, let’s break down the roles of the key players.
The Principal (Seller)
The seller is the primary client in a subagency relationship. They hire a listing broker to market their property and find a buyer. The seller’s interests are the top priority, and all agents involved owe them fiduciary duties.
You may also read (does a recession really lower house prices).
The Listing Broker/Agent
The listing broker is the agent directly hired by the seller. They are responsible for:
- Marketing the property.
- Negotiating offers on behalf of the seller.
- Appointing subagents, if necessary, to expand the property’s exposure.
The Subagent
The subagent is a real estate agent who assists the listing broker in finding a buyer for the property. Key points about subagents:
- They are not directly hired by the seller but work under the listing broker’s authority.
- They owe fiduciary duties to the seller, not the buyer.
- They interact with buyers during showings and negotiations but must prioritize the seller’s interests.
Real-Life Example
Imagine a seller hiring a listing broker to sell their home. The listing broker collaborates with another agent (the subagent) to show the property to potential buyers. Although the subagent interacts with buyers, their loyalty ultimately lies with the seller.
How Subagency Works in a Home Real Estate Transaction
Let’s walk through a typical transaction involving a subagency.
Step-by-Step Breakdown
- Seller Hires a Listing Broker: The seller signs a listing agreement with a broker to market their property.
- Listing Broker Appoints a Subagent: To increase exposure, the listing broker allows other agents to act as subagents.
- The subagent shows the property, interacting with potential buyers to answer questions and facilitate showings.
- Negotiations and Closing: The subagent communicates offers to the listing broker, who negotiates on the seller’s behalf.
Case Study
Consider a scenario where a buyer contacts an agent to view a property. Unbeknownst to the buyer, this agent is a subagent representing the seller. While the agent may seem helpful, their legal obligation is to secure the best deal for the seller.
Fiduciary Duties and Legal Obligations in Subagency
Subagents owe several fiduciary duties to the seller, including:
Loyalty
Subagents must prioritize the seller’s interests above all else, even when interacting with buyers.
Confidentiality
Subagents cannot disclose sensitive information about the seller, such as their willingness to accept a lower price.
Disclosure
Subagents must disclose all material facts about the property to potential buyers.
Reasonable Care
Subagents are expected to act competently and diligently in their role.
Legal Requirements
Real estate laws often require agents to disclose their agency relationships to all parties. Failure to do so can result in legal consequences and loss of trust.
Subagency vs. Other Agency Relationships
Here’s a quick comparison of subagency and other agency types:
Agency TypeWho is RepresentedFiduciary Duty Owed ToCommon Scenarios
Subagency Seller The Seller Listing broker appoints a subagent to find buyers.
Buyer’s Agency Buyer Buyer Buyer’s agent represents the buyer exclusively.
Dual Agency Both Both (limited) One agent represents both buyer and seller.
Transaction Brokerage Neither None Agent assists with paperwork, not representation.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Subagency
Advantages
- Increased Exposure: More agents are working to sell the property.
- Streamlined Process: Simplifies transactions by aligning agents under the seller’s interests.
Disadvantages
- Conflicts of Interest: Buyers may feel unrepresented.
- Limited Buyer Protection: Subagents prioritize the seller’s interests, not the buyer’s.
- Legal Risks: Miscommunication or lack of disclosure can lead to disputes.
Subagency in Today’s Real Estate Market
Subagency is less common today due to the rise of buyer’s agency. Modern buyers prefer agents who exclusively represent their interests. However, subagency still exists in certain regions and situations, particularly in rural or less competitive markets.
You may also read (how to understand a poa in home real estate).
